With the fantasy football trade deadline looming (Dec. 2), I’ll have a column next week on the top candidates to move. So, to build up to the deadline, this is a good opportunity to write about my current trust levels with pass catchers in the league.
These are wide receivers and tight ends who are trending up and those who are starting to lose my trust based on their usage, route deployment and declining production. I’m not saying there are cut candidates in here, as most players still have some level of value, but the point of the column is to give managers the data and analysis they need to make lineup decisions in the critical weeks ahead.
There are 15 players below broken down into four separate categories: pass catchers to trust, not to trust, those to expect less from and also a couple of deeper-league targets.
Pass catchers to trust
Diggs can still shake coverage. It’s on the tape. And he can catch touchdowns, too. Diggs, who has six scoring receptions on the season, now has a TD in three of his past four games. Diggs is also scoring 14.4 fantasy PPG during this stretch, averaging seven targets per game. While Diggs isn’t an explosive playmaker at this stage of his career, he has the inside/outside alignment flexibility to gain positive matchups for quarterback Jayden Daniels, plus he is slippery after the catch. With some positive matchups looming (CIN, @ARI, @TEN), I like Diggs as a WR2/flex.
DJ Moore, WR, Buffalo Bills
Moore has been banged up this season, and he has missed time. However, in the five full games Moore has played, he has scored at least 12 fantasy points in four of them, with 16 or more in three. And the one game out of the five full Moore played where he didn’t produce double-digit points came in a tough matchup against the Vikings’ chaos-creating defense in Week 9. Moore has a touchdown grab in two of his past three games, with a total of three receptions of 20 or more yards during that stretch. Moore has two tougher upcoming matchups (MIA, KC), but as the top target for Josh Allen in Buffalo’s explosive offense, he can be trusted as a WR2.
Harold Fannin Jr., TE, Cleveland Browns
The Browns are on a bye this week, but Fannin should be played in all formats going forward. Fannin, who was started in only 61.2% of ESPN leagues last week, has scored 16.2 fantasy PPG over his last four. And in the three games during that stretch with Deshaun Watson under center, Fannin had at least six targets and 90 yards receiving. Plus, the upcoming schedule, starting in Week 12, is positive (LV, CIN, ATL). Remember, with both Trey McBride and Brock Bowers now working with rookie quarterbacks, Fannin (who is currently TE4 in scoring) has a path to maintain his momentum and finish the season as a top-five tight end.
Parker Washington, WR, Jacksonville Jaguars
Washington’s production hasn’t been exactly steady (two games with fewer than five points, three with fewer than 15), and he has a catch rate of only 56.3%. However, Washington has scored 28 or more points in two of his past five games, with at least seven targets in four of five. And in coach Liam Coen’s offense, the Jags can get Washington in positive one-on-ones, while also scheming open voids in zone coverage. Washington is an easy mover at the release, plus he can scoot after the catch. In this system, with Trevor Lawrence at quarterback, I’d trust Washington as a higher-end WR2.
Jordyn Tyson, WR, New Orleans Saints
Tyson was active last week against the Panthers, only his second game as a pro after suffering a hamstring injury in camp. The rookie first-rounder caught 11 of 13 targets (both team highs), finishing with 80 yards on 32 routes run. Yes, Chris Olave is still the No. 1 option for the Saints, however, Tyson could continue to see more opportunities if teams roll coverage to Olave. Tyson has the high-level playmaking traits to potentially produce breakout weeks. He’s a solid fit for coach Kellen Moore’s route tree, and his upcoming schedule (@CHI, @CIN, GB, @CAR) could also lead to a heavy passing script for the Saints. Get him in the lineup as a flex.
Josh Downs, WR, Kansas City Chiefs
Patrick Mahomes is going to spread the ball around in Andy Reid’s system, which caps the ceiling of his pass catchers. But if you are looking for a player to put in the WR3 or flex spot, Downs looks like a fit. Yes, we have only one game of tape with Downs in a Chiefs uniform (after he was traded from the Colts), but there are a lot of positives after watching him during the win over the Falcons. Downs scored 15.3 points, catching four of five targets for 53 yards (on only eight routes run) and a touchdown on a schemed wheel route. I would expect Downs’ usage to climb quickly, as the Chiefs have some big-time upcoming matchups (ARI, @BUF, @LAR, @CIN), plus he has the route traits to uncover for Mahomes at multiple levels of the field.
Pass catchers not to trust
Jalen Coker, WR, Carolina Panthers
Coker started the season with a career-best 33.8 points in Week 1 versus the Bears, and he caught a total of 16 of 18 targets over his first two games. Since then, Coker has fewer than 10 points in five of seven games played, and he didn’t record a reception (on four targets) in the Week 10 win over the Saints. With his low-level production in a struggling Panthers pass game, I can’t trust Coker moving forward, despite his physical profile and route traits. He’s a deeper-league WR3 at best at this point.
Tyler Warren, TE, Indianapolis Colts
I love the talent and skill set of Warren. That’s why I had him ranked as a top-five tight end this summer. However, Warren’s production has rapidly declined, as he’s scored fewer than 10 fantasy points in three straight games (5.5 PPG). Plus, I don’t understand his current route deployment. During this stretch, Warren has seen 20 targets, yet he’s averaging only 5.4 air yards per target. He can press the seams, work the corner routes and more. Where is it? This Colts offense (after the trade deadline) has been a rough watch, and Warren’s upcoming schedule is daunting (@HOU, @NYG, BYE, PHI). There’s a reason he’s falling in weekly rankings.
DK Metcalf, Pittsburgh Steelers
I’ve written about Metcalf before in this space and not much has changed. Yes, Metcalf did score 15.4 fantasy points in the Sunday night loss to the Bengals, cashing in on a fourth-quarter touchdown when the game was in control for Cincy. However, that was only Metcalf’s second reception of the night, and he has fewer than 10 points in three of his past five games, despite seeing an average of 7.6 targets in each. With Aaron Rodgers also cooling off, I can’t trust Metcalf as more than a boom/bust flex option moving forward.
Emeka Egbuka, WR, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Egbuka was my guy this summer. I saw breakout potential, but it simply hasn’t hit this season. Egbuka missed two games with an injury, and the Bucs have experienced disruption at quarterback due to Baker Mayfield’s thumb injury — and he is questionable again this week (foot). Egbuka (11.1 PPG) has scored fewer than 10 points in two of his last four games, and he has only two touchdown grabs on the season. Another thing working against Egbuka: this Tampa offense has attempted the fewest passes in the league (240). You can still play him, but he needs to remain as a flex option only.
A.J. Brown, WR, New England Patriots
Drake Maye (ankle) could be done for the season and Brown is dealing with yet another injury (hamstring). Brown has played in only four games for the Patriots (6.0 PPG), and he could miss more time. Without Maye, managers must downgrade the entire Patriots pass game with No. 2 Tommy DeVito in line to start in Week 12 versus the Chargers (after the team returns from the bye). When Brown is ready to return, he shouldn’t be viewed as anything better than a WR3. It’s been a tough year for the veteran receiver.
Expect less from these pass catchers
Trey McBride, TE, Arizona Cardinals
McBride is still a must-start, but it’s fair to question whether he will continue to produce elite numbers with rookie Carson Beck now under center. In Beck’s first NFL start this past Sunday, McBride scored a season-low 8.7 points in the loss to the Rams. Beck will go through some growing pains until he adjusts to pro speed/scheme, and that could impact McBride’s numbers.
Deebo Samuel Sr., WR, San Francisco 49ers
Samuel scored a season-high 25.9 points in the Week 10 win over the Cowboys, catching three passes for 30 yards and a touchdown, plus he added 78 yards rushing (on three carries) and another score. Coach Kyle Shanahan will continue to scheme touches for Samuel, as we saw on his 70-yard touchdown run against the poor Dallas defense, but with Mike Evans expected back and Keenan Allen joining the team via trade, Samuel can be used as nothing more than a touchdown-dependent WR3 or flex.
Deeper-league pass catchers to consider
Malachi Fields, WR, New York Giants (9.1% rostered)
Fields has scored 9.5 fantasy PPG over his past three, and he’s averaging 4.7 targets during that stretch. With the aggressive throwing mentality of Giants quarterback J.J. McCarthy, Fields can make plays as a boundary option with his 6-foot-4, 222-pound frame.
Antonio Williams, WR, Washington Commanders (17.6% rostered)
Williams has scored 10 or more points in two of his past three games, and he has seen a total of 15 targets during this stretch. A savvy receiver with route traits and coverage awareness, Williams also caught a touchdown in last week’s win over the Giants (his first since Week 1).
