HomeSportsWhat does a fair fantasy hockey trade offer for Connor McDavid look...

What does a fair fantasy hockey trade offer for Connor McDavid look like?

“McDavid’s controlling every single game he’s playing right now. He’s on a whole different level than anyone else in the League right now.” – Panthers forward Matthew Tkachuk, following Edmonton’s 5-2 win over Florida

Reflecting back to preseason fantasy discussions, it’s almost adorable how earnestly and robustly many of us debated which skater should be selected first overall. Even more delightfully cute, mind you, for fantasy managers who happened to acquire Connor McDavid either through a cunning sense of insight, or because a manager with a higher draft pick instead selected Nathan MacKinnon, Nikita Kucherov, Macklin Celebrini or other. Remember, McDavid was projected to take a minor step back in the production department under Mike Babcock’s fresh defense-first system. Right. Now we’re keeping daily track of where the league’s top producer — a ridiculous 55 points in 23 games thus far — is pacing out relative to Wayne Gretzky’s 215 points earned 1985-86. For hockey fans everywhere, this is a treat to experience.

Which also, getting back to our specific intents and purposes, inspires the question: What’s McDavid’s fantasy trade value now? Everyone has a price, including the league’s list-of-one ultra-megastar. So, after scanning some public trade boards for what the elite center is actually commanding in return — in some cases way too much and others not early enough — I threw out the query to fellow managers across the continent, including those in my Fantasy Sports & Gaming Association Champions League. My straw poll, focussed on fantasy redraft competition (we can open up the conversation to include keeper leagues at a later date) drew a rather consistent response, including the following samples:

“You’d have to be convinced you’d have an opportunity to win the league off of a trade like that. I’d need three top-15 players. Kirill Kaprizov, Macklin Celebrini and Evan Bouchard? And I’d probably have to be in a situation where I was bumping some non-contributors from my roster with those players.”

“In a 12 team redraft league, I’d want one of Leon Draisaitl, Nikita Kucherov, Celebrini, or Nathan MacKinnon (once healthy) plus another significant piece. For instance, Kucherov plus Bouchard or Draisaitl plus Eichel. I’d consider McDavid pretty much untouchable, so the offer would need to be a haul. Wouldn’t want a goalie, they’re too volatile.”

“Because it is fantasy hockey, any trade is possible. It truly depends on the league and format. I did see McDavid go for something crazy like Jesper Wallstedt, Leon Draisaitl, and Adam Fox recently.”

“I’m not giving him away for anything. My league is too small. So is my roster. He carries too much weight.”

The last point is critical. In shallow leagues with precious few lineup spots, it’s difficult to justify moving such a fantasy outlier — one capable of singularly seizing weekly victory in head-to-head competition — for anything less than two other exceptional skaters. It makes little sense to jettison the only NHLer who’s averaging more than 4.0 fantasy points/game, along with being forced to move another reasonably valuable performer, say David Pastrnak or Beckett Sennecke, to accommodate a top-tier individual and player near equal in value to a Pastrnak or Sennecke etc. Right? The fantasy math doesn’t make sense. Especially when considering McDavid posts the most legit potential to go off any night of the week. So this is only worth examining in deeper leagues where, as touched on above, a two-or-more-for-one-deal involves dropping so-called non-contributors to make room for other valued performers.

Under that established umbrella, I once again harassed my fellow managers on who they would actually move to acquire the best player on the planet. Turns out there’s little appetite to relinquish Draisaitl or Bouchard as part of a package, which makes sense since both exceptional players also benefit every game from battling alongside McDavid. In fact, thanks to his goal-scoring prowess, Draisaitl is averaging more fantasy points per game than his running mate these past three weeks. Bouchard is the only 3.0-plus point defender in ESPN standard leagues. On the other hand, most agreed Kucherov, MacKinnon (when healthy), Celebrini, and others might be worth surrendering, depending on who else needed to be included in the deal.

Okay, so after polling several esteemed members of the fantasy hockey community, perusing online trade market boards, and crunching some numbers, I’m offering the following list of boxes to check involving a deal for Edmonton’s No. 97. Take note, this entire exercise falls under the necessary assumption that McDavid remains healthy for the majority of the season, and, as in real life, maintains the fair spirit of both managers benefiting from the deal. From McDavid’s manager’s perspective:

  1. Your league comprises at least 150 total skaters and McDavid takes up less than approximately 5% of your lineup when active. Otherwise, unless your trading partner is relinquishing more than one exceptional performer, you’re not getting back fair value in exchange for giving up another otherwise valuable contributor.

  2. The math adds up, obviously. For instance, in a two-for-one — which I’d stick with unless your league is exceptionally large and/or you sport several substantial roster flaws — at least one regular skater averaging more than 3.0 and another around the 2.7 range. Otherwise, the arithmetic doesn’t make sense for such a singular fantasy powerhouse.

  3. You’re satisfying a positional weakness. Stacked up front but your fantasy blue line stinks? Assuming Bouchard isn’t part of the discussion, how about Matthew Schaefer or similar along with a top-10 forward? A league peer with a more balanced lineup should be willing to broker such an arrangement.

  4. You’re in deep goaltending doo-doo. While I don’t disagree that goalies are often volatile, you’re also not winning anything with a really vulnerable crease. Without question, there are managers out there who drafted Sergei Bobrovsky, Scott Wedgewood or Igor Shesterkin (IR) who are now facing a long, miserable season. Unless, of course they acquire a netminding heavyweight, plus more, in exchange for the Oilers captain.

  5. You feel McDavid’s current 2.4 point/game run is substantially unsustainable. Hardly an unreasonable hunch considering he’s still a human being and, as we’ve been reminded recently by the man himself, not a robot. A quarter into the season, other teams are undoubtedly going to increase their focus on muffling the guy.

Source link

RELATED ARTICLES

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments