HomeSportsWeek 12 Game Day Kickoff: Appreciating Jeremiah Smith's greatness

Week 12 Game Day Kickoff: Appreciating Jeremiah Smith’s greatness

Depending on the perspective through which you view the 2026 season so far, it is either a clear-cut case for why playoff expansion to 24 teams is a necessity or why it’s an absolute travesty.

On the one hand, there’s a dearth of teams that look to be true championship contenders. If we set the bar for what a playoff team should look like after 10 games as a power-conference school with three or fewer losses or a one-loss team from the Group of 6, our combined tally is just 24.

That’s less than any other year of the playoff era. It’s 10 fewer than last year.

Or let’s really lower the bar. How many teams have no more than three losses, none of which came against a team currently outside the FPI top 40, and at least one win vs. an FPI top-25 team? Answer: 13.

Or how about this one: Last year, Notre Dame was the first team left out of the playoff. Its FPI at this point in the 2025 season was 22.4. How many teams are better than that today? Six. The point is, if you’re looking for great, it’s slim pickings.

But what if you’re just looking for “interesting”? Because if the 24-team playoff isn’t likely to provide us with a cadre of new title contenders, it certainly is going to open the door to a lot more late-season games with significant import in the battle for spots 21, 22, 23 and 24.

Take, for example, the lackluster slate of Week 12 this year. ESPN’s “College GameDay” is headed to Miami to witness the Hurricanes wallop a Virginia Tech team that just lost by 18 to Stanford. Fox’s “Big Noon Kickoff” is traveling to Division II Ferris State for its first-round playoff game against Truman State.

But what if we had the 24-team playoff already? Suddenly the snooze-fest of Week 12 becomes as deep as the snow drifts in the parking lot of a Syracuse Walmart.

Right now, SMU‘s trip to Notre Dame is all but meaningless. The Mustangs were whipped by Wake Forest last week, and despite a 7-3 record, didn’t crack the committee’s top 25. But beat Notre Dame on the road and SMU’s case for a spot in the 24-team playoff becomes an intriguing debate.

Right now, Kentucky‘s game at Missouri is a showdown between two once fun stories that have unraveled like the latter seasons of “How I Met Your Mother,” where most of the audience is just hanging on to see how Ted finds the mother or how Eli Drinkwitz finds a new job. But in the 24-team playoff era, this is a huge matchup — a game that puts the winner in position to host a home game and puts the loser on the outside looking in.

Right now, LSU–Tennessee is effectively relegated to a hate watch, where the most interesting question is how much lower Lane Kiffin can go. He already has four losses and is dropping F-bombs in news conferences, and his bad attitude during his morning yoga sessions is ruining everyone’s chi. The Tigers are down bad enough that it hardly seems worth it for Tennessee fans to pelt him with golf balls and mustard packets. But in a 24-team playoff, fire away!

The same narrative is true for South Carolina, which the committee has absolved of all sins committed against Arkansas because of LaNorris Sellers‘ injury, now with a chance to make a statement by knocking off No. 1.

Oregon, Oklahoma and Texas A&M could have major playoff implications in a 24-team format, too. Instead, we’ll watch the Sooners and Aggies trade punts and destroy what little remains of their QBs’ once impressive legacies for nothing.

This is the tradeoff we get by expanding the postseason. On one hand, it has watered down what it means to be a playoff team, and it has taken a good bit of the shine off what had seemed like do-or-die matchups such as last week’s Texas-LSU thriller. On the other hand, expanding playoff access means there’d be a reason to watch Illinois host Iowa this week other than losing a bet or being a member of Hank Brown’s immediate family.

Whether turning late-season games between a couple of four-loss teams into a de facto play-in game constitutes progress is one of those “eye of the beholder” things, but what’s inarguable is that handing out a few more participation trophies would at least ensure the penultimate Saturday of college football’s regular season would have plenty of games with at least as much cachet as the one featuring teams from Kirksville, Missouri, and Big Rapids, Michigan.

Jump to:
Top games | Under the radar
Upset alert | Power rankings
Heisman five | Two-minute drill

Best of the rest of Week 12

Ohio State at Nebraska

Let’s take a moment to fully appreciate the greatness of Jeremiah Smith. Last week, he set a Big Ten record with his 17th 100-yard game. To put that into perspective, in the past decade, all Iowa players combined have 16 100-yard games.

But let’s not worry too much about career numbers. Let’s focus on what Smith, widely understood to be the best receiver in the country with double-teams galore and now with an injured QB, has done lately.

Smith leads the country with 25 contested catches. That’s seven more than any other Power 4 player. The margin between Smith and No. 2 on the list is the same as the margin from No. 2 to No. 13. Just eight other Power 4 players have half as many as he’s got.

Or how about this: Smith has 58 catches that have gone for a first down or touchdown. That’s 13 more than any other Power 4 receiver, and the margin between him and No. 2 is the same as the margin between No. 2 and No. 23. If he only had those catches that went for a first down or touchdown, Smith would still lead the Power 4 in receiving yards.

Smith is magical, regardless of his QB.

Nebraska has its own type of magic though. It somehow manages to saw itself in half and make its fans disappear by the fourth quarter every time it plays a ranked foe. The Huskers have lost 31 straight against ranked foes, and to snap the streak this week, they’ll need to keep Smith in check. So, go ahead and mark it down as 32.

Virginia Tech at Miami

In the past two weeks, Miami has faced off against two top-25 passing defenses without its best receiver, Heisman contender Malachi Toney.

In those two games, against Notre Dame and Duke, Darian Mensah has still thrown for 686 yards, four touchdowns and just one pick, with 10 completions of 20 yards or more, and averaged nearly 8 yards per pass.

Perhaps instead of Toney’s injury derailing Mensah’s Heisman campaign, it clarified it. The Miami QB is a superstar — with or without Toney.

This week, Mensah gets a Virginia Tech secondary that ranks 103rd in opponent passer rating, 106th in yards-per-pass allowed, and has surrendered 91 points to SMU and Stanford in the past two weeks.

UCLA at Michigan

UCLA‘s defense ranks No. 2 in the country in success rate vs. FBS opponents (66.9%). Michigan‘s is No. 6 (62.6%).

UCLA’s defense ranks 13th in explosive play rate (9.08%), while Michigan’s ranks fourth (7.62%).

UCLA’s defense ranks third nationally in points per drive allowed (1.11), and Michigan’s ranks 20th (1.53).

UCLA’s D is third in SP+. Michigan’s is seventh.

We could keep going but this has already gone on longer than any Wolverines drive will Saturday.

Texas Tech at Baylor

Are we, as a society, prepared for the eventuality of Tommy Castellanos starting a College Football Playoff game? It’s an almost impossible notion to fully grasp, but the odds are stacked in his favor.

After winning in court — then losing, then winning again — he has taken over the starting job from Will Hammond at Texas Tech, and the results have been impressive. In his past three games as starter, he has tallied 1,026 total yards, 12 touchdowns and just one turnover, and is averaging better than 10 yards per pass. Between this and Florida State winning its first two road games in three years after he got fired, it has been a rough few weeks for Mike Norvell.


Under-the-radar games

Wake Forest at Georgia Tech

Wake Forest has beaten its past six opponents by at least 24 points each and won its past four by a combined score of 218-21.

Next up: arguably the worst team in the Power 4 not named Maryland.

This one could get ugly against Georgia Tech, but there’s something inherently fun about watching the Deacons utterly eviscerate an opponent — like Roger Ebert reviewing “North” or Jimmy Sexton negotiating new contracts during a Tennessee coaching search. There’s a certain level of reassurance in seeing the truly great ones remind us all that there is an order to things.

North Carolina at Virginia

The winner of this one gets a bowl bid. For Virginia, that’s not exactly a compliment. A year after winning 11 games and making it to the ACC championship game, the Cavaliers have collapsed, stumbling to the finish line of a disappointing season.

For North Carolina, on the other hand, being 5-5 after 10 games ranks somewhere between finding $20 in the pocket of an old coat and Costco having free samples of those Swedish meatballs on the scale of pleasant surprises. With Freddie Kitchens, Michael Lombardi and Steve Belichick all gone before the season began, and Jordon Hudson returning Bill Belichick’s texts with “New phone, who dis?” Carolina has played with a level of competency few believed possible. Even the losses — to Clemson by eight, Notre Dame by 11, Syracuse by one, Miami by three and Louisville by two — have been reminders that UNC belongs on the field with anyone.

Will that translate to another year in Chapel Hill for Belichick? The jury is clearly still out, as UNC president Lee Roberts said there has been no talk of an extension for the six-time Super Bowl winner. But a win against Virginia and a bowl game guarantee would certainly make a clear cast that the ship is headed in the right direction.

Houston at West Virginia

How tough is it to fill out a top-25 ballot these days?

Houston has lost two of its past three games, including arguably the ugliest loss of the year by a ranked team last week against Colorado. Its lone win in that span was by a touchdown over a slumping Cincinnati. It has been more than a month since the Cougars won a game by double digits. Back then, Houston was 5-1 and the No. 20 team in the country.

Now, Houston is ranked … 20th.

The Cougars are basically like Buster Keaton with the house falling down around him as he stands there, unaware, in exactly the right place to remain unharmed.

But don’t count on that luck continuing in Week 12. A road trip to West Virginia is never easy, but given Houston’s struggling defense, Michael Hawkins — the FBS leader with 20 rushing touchdowns — could have a field day, thus dropping Houston all the way to No. 22 in the rankings.


Upset alert

New Mexico (at Wyoming)

New Mexico’s playoff hopes already took a massive hit last week with a loss to UNLV, and things could get worse in Week 12. Wyoming has won five straight and is 4-0 at home this year, and it has a sophomore running back named Samuel “Tote” Harris, who has 194 yards rushing and three touchdowns the past two weeks. That’s a lot of good mojo in the Cowboys’ favor.

Northwestern (at Minnesota)

There are just five of the Big Ten’s 18 teams that have had the same starting QB for all 10 games this season. Minnesota is one of them. (USC, Nebraska, Purdue and Penn State are the others.) And while it’s nice that at least one prominent Minnesota football team has some QB certainty, the Gophers would still probably love to be able to trade for Kirk Cousins, too. Drake Lindsey has gone five straight games without completing 60% of his passes, his 6.1 yards-per-attempt ranks 123rd among qualified QBs, and his 43.0 Total QBR is the fifth worst among qualified Power 4 passers. Still, life isn’t exactly better for Northwestern, which has dropped three straight. Slight edge here to Minnesota for at least shaking things up by firing offensive coordinator Greg Harbaugh Jr.

Florida State (vs. NC State)

NC State hired former QB Philip Rivers as its new coach, and while he won’t be running the show for this year’s team, he has at least brought some new energy to Raleigh as NC State tries to rally to make a bowl game. Florida State, meanwhile, has won its last two, putting the Seminoles one win away from getting to a bowl for the first time since 2023 with interim coach Rick Stockstill. Unfortunately, there are rules about FSU having nice things, and while we may not agree with it, we’re forced to abide by them.


Post-Week 11 power rankings

A look back at the biggest movers and shakers from last week’s action.

1. Alabama, which overcame a tough SEC road opponent despite not playing its best. That’s the sign of a true champion.
2. Clemson, where everything is fine according to the dog sipping coffee amid an inferno
3. Wake Forest
4. Interviewing Brian Kelly
5. Left-for-dead Arch Manning (again!)
6. Bill Belichick looking like a bouncer from “Road House”
7. Stanford
8. Arizona, moving up four spots in the CFP Top 25 after a loss
9. Firing your OC
10. Getting revenge on teams for delaying a game because of travel issues

Not ranked: Getting revenge on Mario Cristobal, connecting flights, Lane Kiffin, second-half Cal, healthy Big Ten QBs


Heisman five

We’re closing in on the end of the season, and the contenders — the realistic ones anyway — seem pretty clear. Jeremiah Smith, Darian Mensah, Gunner Stockton, Devon Dampier and CJ Carr make up the list, with perhaps some long-shot options such as Gio Lopez, Nate Sheppard or, yes, Arch Manning still technically in the mix.

play

1:09

Manny Diaz makes the case for Nate Sheppard to be a Heisman finalist

But for this week’s ranking, we wanted to go off the board entirely and rank our top five players getting zero Heisman love who deserve to be in the conversation as the nation’s best college football player.

1. Utah LT Zereoue Williams

Dampier is getting a lot of much-deserved attention for leading the Utes to a 10-0 record and the No. 2 ranking in the country, but his success comes in no small part as a result of the astounding work being done up front by the Utah offensive line. And no one on that line has been bigger than Williams. For the season, Williams has allowed just two pressures, no sacks and blown two run blocks. He has just three total blown blocks all year. No other full-time Power 4 left tackle has fewer than seven, and only three have fewer than 10. In 621 snaps, he has been called for zero holds and just one false start. Williams is operating at another level from any other O-lineman in the country, and he has been the cream to Dampier’s Mountain Dew that has made Utah’s offense so dirty.

This week: Utah travels to TCU looking to remain undefeated.

2. Clemson CB Ashton Hampton

There are two ways of looking at the situation at Clemson right now. There’s Dabo Swinney’s view that the Tigers have some nice pieces and are but a few plays away from being 6-2. It is a good team that has the potential for greatness, and with a little more time, it’s all going to work itself out. Then there’s the perspective that literally every other human on earth agrees to be true: Clemson is a train wreck with an engineer still trying to pilot the train farther off the tracks. In either case, Hampton has been a delightful silver lining. He has allowed completions on just 26.8% of his targets, the second-best rate nationally among cornerbacks, hasn’t allowed a touchdown and has given up just one completion of more than 10 yards all season, has a pair of interceptions and ranks third nationally with 12 pass breakups. Opposing passers have a 0.8 QBR when targeting him this year. And consider he has been able to do all this despite not getting to pad his stat sheet against Clemson’s quarterbacks.

This week: Clemson visits Duke, where Sheppard could throw for more yardage than the Tigers do.

3. Toledo DE Andrew Zock

The statistical case for Zock is exceptional. He has racked up 17 tackles for loss and 11.5 sacks, both good for second in the country, an FBS-best 31 tackles at or behind the line of scrimmage, 30 solo tackles (third among FBS D-linemen) and — wait for it — 57 pressures, 13 more than any other defensive lineman in the country. But there’s a more emotional, more relevant case, too. It’s really fun to say “Zock.”

This week: Toledo hosts Bowling Green with at least a flicker of hope for the Group of 6’s playoff spot remaining.

4. Iowa State RB Aiden Flora

The Cyclones’ roster was decimated when Matt Campbell left for Penn State, but Flora, who had just 15 carries in his career, stuck around. Iowa State is glad he did. The Cyclones are now one win away from getting bowl eligible, and Flora is the biggest reason why. He leads the nation in rushing with 1,335 yards, and he’s third in yards per carry (7.22) among backs with at least 100 totes. He has gone for 200 yards in three of his past six games, and he has racked up 735 all-purpose yards over his past three.

This week: Iowa State travels to UCF before wrapping the season with Kansas State. A win in either will mean bowl eligibility, and a win in both would be the first time Iowa State had seven regular-season victories under a coach other than Campbell since 2005.

5. FAU WR Easton Messer

Fun fact: Messer has 13 receiving touchdowns, two rushing touchdowns, two punt return touchdowns and a passing touchdown this year. The last time any FBS player had at least 18 total TDs, and one each receiving, rushing, passing and as a returner, was Saquon Barkley in 2017, and the only other player to do it with a punt return (rather than a kickoff return) in the past 20 years was Clemson’s C.J. Spiller in 2009. That’s some elite company for a guy who began his career as a walk-on at Western Kentucky.

This week: FAU hosts USF in a battle to determine American Conference hierarchy in the state of Florida. Both are 6-4.


Two-minute drill

It has been a while since we’ve been able to break out this stat, but thankfully on the penultimate weekend of the regular season, the SEC provides a full slate of FCS matchups to make it relevant once again: Power 4 teams are 55-0 against FCS opponents this year, winning by an average of 46 points per game. Just two have been within 10 points in the fourth quarter at any point. Twelve have been decided by 60 or more. Last year, the FCS was 0-60 vs. Power 4 teams. In 2024, it was 0-58. In 2023, it was 1-53 with the lone victory coming from Sacramento State against a woeful Stanford team. Sacramento State is now an FBS member.

And yet this week, we’ll see Ole Miss prove it deserves its top-25 ranking by hosting Wofford. Alabama will certainly validate the committee’s No. 3 ranking with a huge home game against Chattanooga. Mississippi State can finally break its six-game losing streak if it can somehow survive Tennessee Tech. And Auburn hosts Samford in a game Alex Golesh surely dreamed of coaching when he was a boy in Russia with little more than a dusty old transistor radio, a few turnips and a vision of one day tasting the glory of beating the sixth-best team in the Southern Conference.

It’s time to make it stop. The committee will have a hard enough job figuring out who belongs in a 24-team playoff field next year. The job doesn’t need to be made harder by throwing away one of 12 data points on a game that can accomplish nothing other than getting a key player hurt.

Indiana at Washington

With backup Grant Wilson at QB, Indiana toppled USC 27-13 last week. Wilson threw for 305 yards and two scores in the victory. It’s the most the Hoosiers have scored in a game since early October against Rutgers and marked the first time Indiana threw for 300 yards in a game since beating Wisconsin last November. Even wilder, it’s the first time an Indiana QB has thrown for 300 yards in a win over a power-conference foe with a winning record since Connor Bazelak in 2022.

Arkansas at Texas

Why does this feel like the perfect chance for Arch Manning to complete 52% of his throws for 106 yards and two bad picks, but connect on a late TD to Cam Coleman to close out an utterly forgettable 24-10 Texas win?

Vanderbilt at Florida

Vanderbilt has just nine passing touchdowns all season. Three of them came against NC State. What are the odds that wouldn’t be the most embarrassing part of that performance for the Wolfpack? Oddly, Vandy might not be the team with bigger QB issues in this one. Florida‘s passers over the past five games have thrown just three touchdowns and seven interceptions, while averaging just a tick more than 5 air yards per throw.

Syracuse at Boston College

Calvin Russell III tore an Achilles on March 30. Just 230 days later — last Saturday, to be precise — he caught 17 passes in a win over NC State. That’s a genuinely remarkable recovery that should be studied by doctors, scientists and maybe Gerry McNamara, who could probably use another small forward. Russell’s performance marks just the second time in the past 20 years an ACC player had 17 catches in a single conference game. The other was also a Syracuse receiver (Ervin Phillips) in 2017… also against NC State.

Old Dominion at UConn

Old Dominion has surrendered 44 sacks this year, the most in the FBS. How bad is that? In the playoff era, there are only nine other examples of an FBS team allowing at least 44 sacks through 10 games. The truly wild thing though is two of the other examples are also Old Dominion. In 2019, the Monarchs had allowed 45 sacks at this point, and in 2023, they had given up 52. And it gets worse. It’s not just the QB taking a beating in the backfield. ODU has had 135 runs stopped at or behind the line of scrimmage this year — 37.7% of its total run plays. That’s 23 more than any other FBS team. The difference between the Monarchs and the next-worst team (West Virginia) is the same as the difference between WVU and No. 28. Surely there are just some heavyset dudes with surly attitudes wandering around Norfolk, Virginia, that Old Dominion could sign and ask to just stand in front of some defenders for a couple of games, right?

Source link

RELATED ARTICLES

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments