HomeEntertainmentWar is not an option

War is not an option

The India Army’s BrahMos missile launcher is displayed during the Republic Day parade in New Delhi, India, January 26, 2026. — Reuters

Over the past several decades, India has sought to develop military capabilities and propounded accompanying doctrines, designed to crush or coerce Pakistan and impose its hegemony.

Since the advent of the Modi-led BJP-RSS government, India’s strategic posture has featured expansionist ambitions, avoidance of conflict resolution and ideologically driven military recklessness. Unfortunately, India’s self-image as a great power and regional hegemon was encouraged by Western indulgence and special treatment, such as the NSG nuclear supplier’s exception, description as a ‘net security provider’, foundational military cooperation agreements with the US, inclusion in the Quad, and access to advanced Western technologies and weapons systems.

India’s doctrine, and attempts in 2019 and again in 2024, to wage a ‘limited war (against Pakistan) under the nuclear overhang’ reflected India’s confidence in its military superiority and political impunity.

Pakistan responded to India’s unilateral aggression on May 6, 2025 against civilian sites with a ‘quid pro quo plus’ response in accordance with its doctrine of full spectrum deterrence, shooting down several of the attacking Indian aircraft. With its air force grounded for the next 48 hours, India resorted to drone and missile attacks.

Pakistan responded, again in accordance with its QPQ+ doctrine, one step up the escalation ladder by launching Operation Bunyanum Marsoos targeting scores of Indian air bases, missile sites and anti-ballistic missile systems. At this stage, India no doubt realised that the conflict would not remain limited and Pakistan would continue to retaliate against Indian attacks at ever higher levels. Despite its subsequent denials, India sought urgent US intervention to secure Pakistan’s agreement to a ceasefire.

Having suffered military humiliation, the Modi government has tried to save face by making several false and provocative statements, for example, that its Operation Sindoor has been merely ‘paused’, not ended, and India will attack Pakistan automatically in response to any terrorist incident in India. Most dangerously, India has asserted that it has ‘called Pakistan’s nuclear bluff’.

India has continued to create a strategic environment which could trigger another conflict. It has put the Indus Waters Treaty in abeyance and threatened to cut off Pakistan’s legitimate access to the waters of the three Western rivers of the Indus Basin. It has threatened to take over Azad Jammu and Kashmir. It has intensified its campaign of terrorism against Pakistan, especially from the territory of Taliban-ruled Afghanistan. It has refused any dialogue with Pakistan to resolve outstanding disputes.

Militarily, India has moved to ‘cannisterise’ its nuclear weapons and ‘mated’ nuclear weapons with its submarine-launched missiles. This provides India not only a second-strike capability but also a preemptive-strike capability. It reveals the hollowness of India’s no-first-use doctrine.

In contrast, Pakistan has expressed its readiness for a dialogue with India to resolve outstanding disputes, including Kashmir. It has called for adherence to the IWT and international law. It has demanded the end of Indian-sponsored terrorism.

Militarily, Pakistan has taken steps to assure its ability to control and dominate the escalation ladder in a future conflict. It has created the conventional Fatah intermediate- range missile force capable of reaching all of India’s far-flung military facilities. It has visibly separated its nuclear strategic command. And it has consolidated command and control of air, sea and land forces – conventional and strategic – in the office of the CDF.

India must make a sober analysis of the consequences of its irresponsible policies and posture. There are zero prospects that India can either coerce or militarily defeat Pakistan. The Pakistani defence forces, and the Pakistani nation, have demonstrated the will and the capability to respond effectively to Indian aggression at any level of conflict.

Pakistan desires the peaceful resolution of disputes. Yet, its strategic restraint and patience, in the face of Indian provocations, is not unlimited. Pakistan’s strategic partner, China, has demonstrated that it will not allow a threat to Pakistan’s sovereignty and territorial integrity. Indeed, another Indian aggression will be denounced by the entire international community.

Most importantly, neither India nor Pakistan can ignore the possibility of a conflict escalating to the nuclear level. If hostilities start, they would most likely begin from the elevated levels they reached on May 11, 2025. The nuclear threshold could be crossed in several ways:

First, either side, if faced with an existential threat or defeat, will most likely use its nuclear weapons. The Israelis call this the Samson Option. Second, during a conflict, either side could accidentally attack the adversary’s nuclear assets or facilities, evoking a nuclear response.

Third, a deliberate or mistaken attack on either side’s command and control or leadership would probably trigger a nuclear response. Fourth, a conventional attack could be mistaken by the other side as a nuclear strike. India’s use of the Brahmos dual-capable missile during the last conflict was highly irresponsible. Fifth, a field commander could resort to the unauthorised use of nuclear systems. The ‘accidental’ firing onto Pakistan territory of a Brahmas missile in 2022 raised questions about the effectiveness of India’s command and control system. How effectively would this system operate with the commanders of India’s submerged nuclear-armed submarines?

Finally, the possibilities of nuclear use have multiplied in modern, multi-domain war, where dual-use and precision weapons and cyber and electronic systems have blurred the lines between conventional and strategic weapons systems and technologies.

Hopefully, sober minds in New Delhi realise that a war against Pakistan is no longer an option. The wise and responsible course for India and Pakistan would be: One, adopt a robust mechanism for conflict management and strategic stability; and two, resume composite dialogue to resolve outstanding disputes, especially Kashmir, the water issue and terrorism. Alternatively, accept the offers of mediation made by the US, other countries and the UN secretary-general.


The writer, a veteran diplomat, is a former permanent representative of Pakistan to the United Nations.


Disclaimer: The viewpoints expressed in this piece are the writer’s own and don’t necessarily reflect Geo.tv’s editorial policy.




Originally published in The News

Source link

RELATED ARTICLES

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments