Everyone loves the NFL offseason hot stove. Fans get super excited about outside players joining their favorite team, whether through trade or free agency. Those holes on the roster have finally been filled by wily veterans!
Unfortunately, those moves don’t always work out. Some players excel in new surroundings, bringing strong production. Others struggle with their new situation, confirming why they were made available in the first place.
Here’s a look at five players who are working well with their new teams and five who are not. How are the successful new players helping their teams? Which teams find themselves on the hook for bad contracts? Let’s start with a quarterback who has helped two teams this season.
Jump to a section:
Moves that have worked out
Moves that have not yet worked out

Five players who are working


How he got there: Signed a one-year, $11.3 million contract with the Raiders before being traded to the Vikings on Nov. 10
2026 stat to know: 65.0 QBR (10th out of 31 qualifying QBs)
Comparable 2025 stat: 47.6 QBR (not enough passes to qualify)
This is a bit of a special case, because Cousins is thriving in his second new city of the season. Or perhaps we should say one new and one old city, because Cousins played for Minnesota from 2018 to 2023.
His performance this season is further proof that it takes a long time to recover from an Achilles tear. Cousins tore his Achilles in 2023 on the last play of his previous stint with the Vikings. He went to Atlanta in 2024 and was completely immobile on plays such as rollouts and play-action fakes. He put up a career-low QBR of 47.0 and lost the starting job to then-rookie Michael Penix Jr. toward the end of the season. In 2025, Cousins came in after Penix was hurt and looked a bit better. He was able to avoid turnovers, but his yards per attempt average dropped from 7.7 in 2024 to 6.4. It resulted in his QBR virtually being the same as it was the previous season.
But Cousins is back to being his old self this season. His yards per attempt is up to 7.4, and his 22 passing touchdowns rank second in the NFL. His sack rate of 3.9% is also the lowest of any starting quarterback.
The Raiders were able to get four wins out of Cousins (one more than they earned all last season) until they were ready to transition to rookie quarterback Fernando Mendoza. Then they got an additional third-round pick by trading Cousins to Minnesota. Cousins won his first start with the Vikings in Week 10 and dramatically improved their chances of winning the Super Bowl by taking Minnesota’s offense from horrific to slightly above average.

How he got there: Signed a three-year, $43.1 million contract
2026 stat to know: 1.66 rushing yards over expected per attempt (second out of 45 qualifying RBs)
Comparable 2025 stat: 0.25 RYOE/attempt (30th out of 51 qualifying RBs)
Do running backs matter? Well, special running backs are only special when they get enough blocking to do great things. Last season, the Chiefs had the blocking but didn’t have a back who could fully take advantage. This season, they have two in Walker and rookie Emmett Johnson.
Walker has always been good at breaking tackles, but he’s in another universe this season. According to FTN charting, Walker leads the league with a 35.2% avoided tackle rate and is third with 3.14 yards after contact per carry.
The biggest question about Walker in Kansas City was whether he could handle the workload of a clear No. 1 running back after being in a committee in Seattle. Although Walker missed last week with a groin injury, he’s on pace for 318 carries, which would easily exceed his previous career high of 228 set as a rookie in 2022.

How he got there: Signed a three-year, $42.4 million contract
2026 stats to know: minus-12.2% DVOA (63rd out of 79 qualifying WRs), 10.8 yards per target
Comparable 2025 stats: 45.1% DVOA (first out of 58 qualifying WRs), 6.0 yards per target
Evans had a difficult final season in Tampa Bay. Oft-injured QB Baker Mayfield had a hard time getting Evans the ball in places where the receiver could excel. He hit career lows in yards per reception (12.3) and catch rate (48%). Last year was the first season of his career in which he failed to reach 1,000 receiving yards.
Evans has been refreshed and renewed in San Francisco’s powerful offense. His catch rate is up to 69%, which would be the highest of his career. He’s also averaging 15.6 yards per reception. He had 23 first downs on 62 targets in 2025; this season, he’s up to 25 first downs on only 39 targets so far.
The only problem is the Achilles tendinitis that has sidelined Evans since Week 6. The 49ers are being very careful so they can have Evans back and 100 percent for their playoff run. They are hoping he can return in the next couple of weeks and continue to demonstrate why he was such a good signing.

How he got there: Signed a two-year, $13 million contract (up to $17 million with bonuses)
2026 stat to know: Tied for lead among LBs with 20 defeats
Comparable 2025 stat: 15 defeats in 13 games
Williams was a first-team All-Pro for the Jets in 2023 but is still not as well known as his younger brother, Cowboys defensive tackle Quinnen Williams. Quincy had only 12 starts for the Jets last season and turned 30 in August, so it was reasonable to assume that he was at the tail end of his career.
The Browns brought him in on a reasonable contract and stuck him next to Defensive Rookie of the Year Carson Schwesinger, and Williams has been an outstanding playmaker in that role. I keep track of a stat called defeats, which measures defensive splash plays. It combines tackles for loss, turnovers and any play that prevents a third- or fourth-down conversion. Williams has 20 defeats so far this season, tied with the Vikings’ Blake Cashman for the lead among all linebackers. (Quinnen leads all players with 24.)
Williams is known for speed and has been excellent in pass coverage, with four passes defensed and 15 pass tackles, which prevented a successful yardage gain despite a reception. Opposing running backs have fewer than 20 receiving yards per game against the Browns.

How he got there: Signed a three-year, $42 million contract
2026 stats to know: 16 defeats, three interceptions, average run tackle at 3.3 yards
Comparable 2025 stats: 14 defeats, five interceptions, average run tackle at 4.0 yards
Unlike Williams, Lloyd entered the 2026 season with big expectations. He was one of the NFL’s top linebackers last season and signed the largest contract of any free agent off-ball linebacker this past offseason. So far, Lloyd has lived up to that contract.
Entering the season, it was hard to imagine Lloyd getting five interceptions again, but his Week 10 interception already puts him at three. Lloyd already has more defeats than he did last season, too, and he was part of two combined tackles to prevent Saints running back Audric Estime from converting on third-and-short last week. With the NFC South still up for grabs, the Panthers are counting on more big plays from Lloyd to get them back into the postseason.

Five players who are not working

How he got there: Acquired from the Dolphins along with a 2026 fourth-round pick for 2026 first-, third- and fourth-round picks
2026 stat to know: minus-17.6% receiving DVOA (52nd out of 58 qualifying WRs)
Comparable 2025 stat: 11.6% receiving DVOA (19th out of 79 qualifying WRs)
Trading for Waddle was supposed to unlock the Broncos’ intermediate passing game and help Bo Nix complete passes over the middle. Instead, Waddle has been victim of Nix’s struggles. Right now, Nix ranks 26th in DVOA on passes over the middle and 28th on intermediate passes (10-19 air yards). His numbers in those areas are a little better throwing to Waddle than to other receivers, but they are still not good. Nix is also checking down far too often, another reason Waddle isn’t seeing the ball downfield.
An additional issue for Waddle has been injuries, which include a leg injury in training camp and a chest injury in recent weeks that has forced him to be limited in practice. He also left the Week 9 win over the Panthers with a concussion.
Waddle has shown frustration on the field even though the Broncos are winning. The hope is that Nix can do a better job of getting him the ball in the second half of the season, but right now it seems like the Broncos paid a lot of draft value (and took on an expensive contract) for a player their quarterback can’t fully utilize.

How he got there: Signed a two-year, $13 million contract
2026 stat to know: 77.5% pass block win rate (64th out of 65 qualifying guards)
Comparable 2025 stat: 91.9% pass block win rate (40th out of 65 qualifying guards)
OK, this is less of a surprise. In fact, for many who follow the league, the bigger surprise was that the Chargers signed Strange in the first place. A first-round pick of the Patriots in 2022, Strange lost his job in 2024 and wasn’t very good with the Dolphins last season. Was he really an upgrade for a Chargers team that had trouble with its interior offensive line in 2025?
Well, the Chargers are still having interior O-line trouble. Strange is close to the bottom of the league in pass block win rate. He’s better in run block win rate but still below average — 70.7% compared to the league average of 71.3% for guards. You have to imagine the Chargers will be looking for guard help again in 2027.

How he got there: Signed a three-year, $27 million contract
2026 stat to know: minus-20.2% receiving DVOA (37th out of 43 qualifying TEs)
Comparable 2025 stat: minus-11.0% receiving DVOA (43rd out of 55 qualifying TEs)
Okonkwo’s performance this season is fully in line with the first four years of his NFL career in Tennessee, but he was supposed to be more than that for the Commanders. There was hope that he could take another step forward at age 27 to become a major part of Washington’s passing game. Okonkwo himself told the Commanders’ website that “this is the place where I can finally unleash.”
It hasn’t happened. Okonkwo has never matched the three touchdowns (on only 32 catches) or 14.1 yards per reception he had as a rookie in 2022. He’s having another season of reasonable but relatively inefficient production. His 69% catch rate isn’t terrible, but it’s still below average for tight ends, and the same goes for his average of 9.7 yards per reception. Okonkwo also hasn’t found the end zone yet for Washington, but he’ll probably end up with a touchdown or two before the season is over. It’s just a little disappointing because the Commanders hoped for more.

How he got there: Signed a one-year, $1.2 million contract (up to $5 million in incentives)
2026 stat to know: 128.3% coverage DVOA (not enough snaps to qualify but higher is worse)
Comparable 2025 stat: 10.8% coverage DVOA
The Chiefs turned over almost their entire secondary this offseason and have gotten a lot of value out of second-year corner Nohl Williams and first-round rookie Mansoor Delane. But they brought back Sneed, a key player on their back-to-back Super Bowl-winning teams in 2022 and 2023, to play in the slot. That hasn’t worked out as well.
With 148 coverage snaps this season, Sneed just misses the line for my coverage DVOA rankings, but he would easily be at the bottom of the league if he qualified. He gave up big play after big play early in the season. In Week 2, he gave up six first downs, plus a goal-line touchdown by Colts tight end Tyler Warren. Raiders running back Ashton Jeanty had a series of 10-yard completions in Sneed’s zone that moved the sticks in Week 4. And in Week 7, Sneed got roasted by Jaxon Smith-Njigba in the slot, though he’s not the only corner to struggle against JSN.
Sneed went on injured reserve with a knee injury two weeks ago, and it’s hard to know if he’ll have his previous role in Kansas City’s defense back when he returns.

How he got there: Signed a three-year, $58 million contract
2026 stat to know: 62.2% coverage DVOA (89th out of 89 qualifying CBs)
Comparable 2025 stat: 4.2% coverage DVOA (61st out of 92 qualifying CBs)
The Titans signed Taylor away from the Saints with the idea that they could make him an outside cornerback. It didn’t work. Taylor gave up a ton of passes the first few weeks of the season. The nadir was Week 5 against Houston, when Taylor gave up three third-down conversions (including a 9-yard touchdown to Jaylin Noel) and drew a 28-yard pass interference flag.
Taylor was so bad as an outside corner that the Titans benched him. He was a healthy scratch in Week 6 and was active but didn’t play in Week 7. He was moved to the slot in Week 8 when nickelback Marcus Harris got hurt and remained there, despite Harris’ return in Week 10. But Taylor’s play hasn’t improved in the slot, as he gave up a couple of long gains to Jaguars receiver Parker Washington last week.
