HomeBusinessBuilder cancels Bengaluru woman’s Rs 1.65 crore flat despite taking Rs 16.5...

Builder cancels Bengaluru woman’s Rs 1.65 crore flat despite taking Rs 16.5 lakh payment and allots it to another buyer who paid 50% value; Karnataka RERA orders Rs 5 lakh compensation for mental agony and financial loss even as it hears refund case separately

A homebuyer who booked an apartment in Bengaluru found herself embroiled in a dispute with the developer. (Image for representative purpose only)

You book a flat and make part payment for it, and repeatedly follow up for execution of the agreement for sale. Then you discover that the apartment has been allotted to another buyer. What do you do?A homebuyer who booked an apartment in Bengaluru found herself embroiled in a dispute with the developer after alleging that the flat was allotted to another purchaser without her consent.The Karnataka Real Estate Regulatory Authority (K-RERA) has awarded her compensation for the agony. A separate case for refund with interest is pending.

What the case is about

The dispute concerned a homebuyer who bought an apartment in the developer’s project. The woman buyer booked a three-bedroom apartment, with a carpet area of 1,270 sq ft and one car parking space. The allotment letter was issued in 2024, and the total sale consideration was Rs 1,64,99,147.70, inclusive of applicable GST.The woman’s case was that she had agreed to pay 10% of the sale consideration during booking, followed by 30% in 2025, with the remaining amount payable according to a construction-linked schedule from 2026 onwards.The homebuyer alleged that the Bengaluru developer cancelled her apartment allotment without informing her and allotted the same flat to another purchaser.The woman buyer alleged that she had paid towards the booking, arranged funds for the remaining consideration and repeatedly followed up for execution of the agreement for sale.The order records that the payment schedule had been discussed with the promoter’s representative and approved in writing. The homebuyer stated that she made the booking payment in accordance with this arrangement.In fact, she sold another property in 2025, for Rs 1,02,71,250, according to the sale deed discussed in the order. She said she needed the proceeds to arrange funds for the apartment.A draft agreement for sale was emailed to her on January 23, 2025, but she alleged that the developer failed to complete the formalities despite repeated follow-ups.On February 12, 2025, she was informed that a fresh payment demand of Rs 57.74 lakh had been raised in place of an earlier demand of Rs 35 lakh. On June 28, 2025, she received an email seeking her bank details to process a refund. Agarwal maintained that she had neither requested cancellation of the allotment nor sought a refund.The dispute took a decisive turn on October 30, 2025, when she visited the project site. According to the complaint, she discovered that the apartment had been re-allotted to a third party and that an agreement had been executed with the new purchaser.The order also records that, on November 18, 2025, she was informed that the flat could not be allotted to her because another customer had paid 50% of the consideration.Agarwal sought Rs 15 lakh for mental agony and Rs 25 lakh for financial loss and loss of opportunity. The developer did not appear before the authority despite notice, and the complaint proceeded ex parte.

Why did RERA rule in favour of the homebuyer?

Karnataka Real Estate Regulatory Authority considered the allotment letter, payment records, email communications and draft agreement.The order noted that the complainant had paid towards the sale consideration but had not received an executed agreement for sale. It also recorded that an agreement concerning the same apartment had been executed in favour of another purchaser.K-RERA treated the developer’s conduct as inconsistent with its contractual commitments and obligations under the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016. In discussing the absence of an executed agreement despite receipt of payment, the order described this as “a clear violation of RERA Act.”Sunitha Rajesh, Partner at CMS Induslaw tells TOI that the K-RERA order highlights some basic but important principles under the RERA Act.However it is important to note this order is ex-parte i.e., passed without having heard the builder.“The decision was based on one-side of the facts, and the decision may undergo a change in an appeal by the builder,” she says.According to Sunitha Rajesh, the three key facts considered by the authority as are under:First, the builder had collected about Rs 16.5 lakh, which exceeded 10% of the flat’s sale consideration of Rs 1.65 crore, without executing an agreement for sale. The RERA Act does not permit a promoter to collect more than 10% of the sale consideration before entering into an agreement for sale.Second, the builder raised demands that were not in accordance with the agreed payment schedule. A payment schedule accepted by both parties cannot be altered unilaterally.Third, the apartment was allotted to another purchaser while the buyer’s money continued to remain with the builder. The Authority treated this as a unilateral cancellation by the builder and not as refund.“While awarding compensation, the Authority recognised that when a buyer receives only a refund, the buyer loses not only the money paid but also the opportunity to benefit from the property’s appreciation,” Sunitha Rajesh says.“For homebuyers, the case reinforces the importance of ensuring that an agreement for sale is executed before making substantial payments. Buyers should also respond promptly and in writing to any cancellation or refund communication or unilateral changes in the terms agreed at the time of allotment that they do not accept,” she adds.Because this order was passed ex-parte, it may be challenged by the builder and may not be the final word in this matter.In an order dated October 7, 2026, RERA directed the builder to pay the homebuyer Rs 5 lakh towards mental agony, financial loss and loss of opportunity. The developer was also directed to pay Rs 7,000 towards litigation costs.If it failed to comply within 60 days, interest at the marginal cost of funds-based lending rate (MCLR) plus 2% per annum would apply from the 61st day until realisation.The judgment separately records that the homebuyer had filed another complaint seeking a refund with interest, which was pending adjudication.Thus, the October 7 order did not direct the developer to refund the amount she had paid towards the apartment.

Source link

RELATED ARTICLES

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments