HomeLife Style‘Sentimental twaddle’: Indy readers have their say on ‘middle-class’ Christmas ads

‘Sentimental twaddle’: Indy readers have their say on ‘middle-class’ Christmas ads

If there’s one element of Christmas that is a foregone conclusion, it is the agonising appearance of the Christmas advert. The heartfelt piano cover song in the background and the selling of high-end wares with a schmaltzy twist are more certain than Father Christmas checking his list twice these days.

Helen Coffey decided that we’ve all, collectively, had enough of them in an article this week that got our readers talking.

This isn’t to say she called time on a feeling of festive happiness or the purchasing of a gift or two, but just the sheer amount of such adverts there as every shop needs to connect their brand to the holiday season. You can’t move for cameos and mini vol-au-vents.

Lucy Punch plays the character we know and love in the M&S advert
Lucy Punch plays the character we know and love in the M&S advert ( M&S )

Our readers also had a lot to say about this advertising trend in the comments section, with some even questioning if any of them actually achieve what an advert is supposed to and whether, in light of the general chaos of the world, we should count ourselves lucky we’re even able to find any joy at all!

The merry middle class

Reader fastyellosaab was quick to pick up on the fact that, by and large, none of the adverts really deviate from the usual middle-class luxury lifestyle:

“Oh, God yes. The retailers think we are all well-off middle-class customers and the world is a ‘happy, no worries’ place. They are totally wrong. These slushy ads are an insult to the vast majority of the country that is struggling every day.”

Come all ye shoppers

Independent Member Chuckiethebrave pondered on whether the big budget adverts even have a positive effect on a store’s bottom line:

“Would a Christmas TV advert define where you shop?

It is more likely you’re going to shop at the usual stores, based on each individual’s financial pressures.

I don’t think that would change with these annual sickly sweet advertisements.”

Adverts to all and to all a good night!

Reader Practicale had a more positive response to the Christmas ads phenomenon, saying there’s something for everyone:

“For every M&S and John Lewis ad, there’s one for a budget or lower-tier retailer, not to mention items like a car or sofa with an accompanying credit or similar pay-monthly deal for those who are not in the JL/M&S bracket.

Not every advert that appears on TV is aimed at or for everyone.

I don’t have any family; am I supposed to be aggrieved every time an advert shows a family gathered round a table or enjoying each other’s company and having a good time on account of that not being my personal experience?”

Every little hindrance…

Indy Member MikMcMikMc called out a specific advert Helen hadn’t mentioned:

“You can add the embarrassingly turgid Tesco ad too, it’s a farce…”

Silent night

Indy Member PhylisStein actually took the opportunity to give some advice to those who are finding themselves getting worked up over all the commercial cheer:

“There’s an easy solution to being hacked off about these ‘out of touch’ Christmas adverts, those terrible, tin-eared commercial businesses trying to sell stuff to people who want to spend a fortune they don’t have on stuff they and their loved ones probably don’t need…switch off the TV, turn down the radio and make a decision to bow out from the over-commercialised gluttony that Christmas has been turned into courtesy of our favourite high street brands.”

Last Christmas?

Indy Member Roberta00 offered a sobering thought that might help some to joy and others to misery. Stockpile anyone?

“It does feel like peak Christmas. But by next Christmas, who knows what will be happening in the world?”

Festively furious

It sounds as though these kinds of adverts have been on Indy Member Tanaquil’s naughty list for quite some time:

“I reached my limit with this sentimental twaddle a long time ago. They are ads, for goodness sake, not cultural events. They have precisely zero significance other than using saccharine stereotypes to sell stuff.”

Do they know it’s Christmas?

Reader Ian left a comment that shows us all, in the end, ignorance could be bliss as it pertains to these Christmas ads:

“As someone who never watches TV adverts, I wouldn’t know what all the fuss is about.”

Some comments have been edited or shortened for clarity

Source link

RELATED ARTICLES

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments